Remember that book from the 80’s, Women Who Love Too Much? (Subtitled :When You Keep Wishing and Hoping He’ll Change.) Back in the day of this New York Times Bestseller there sprung up groups for, “women who believed being in love means being in pain.” Women who read this book had a history of emotionally unavailable men. I felt I belonged.
At the time I was 24, I’d been divorced for a year and my son was almost two. I was searching for clues about myself and thought I ought to go and check out this group, I bought the book and made the call. The information for this group appeared in the newspaper classifieds. I spoke to a gentleman named Mr. John Hartrader who said he was a Counselor and organized the group. I showed up one evening for this group that met once a week and was charged seven dollars each time. After two meetings I got a call from Mr. Hartrader and he asked me if I might be able to visit with him more after the next session to which I replied I could.
I thought maybe he had some special insight about me — I had been especially outspoken. I’m not sure why I was thinking that he thought I might be a leader or something — all of the women there seemed so closed compared to me. So I went to the next meeting, and kept my babysitter on for an additional hour not knowing what to expect. After the group left he asked if I might be interested in going a few blocks away to the Olive Garden where we could talk and maybe grab a bite.
We met inside the restaurant and took a table. He ordered a bottle of wine and an appetizer and began asking me personal questions that seemed not to be quite what I’d envisioned. So there I was, at the Olive Garden, sitting with a man who organized this group for heartbroken women and he was hitting on me. No, I’m not kidding.
And I asked him how much time he had and let him know I was free the entire evening. That’s when I found out his plan for me … like, I was supposed to be the entree. So I smiled politely and said that I’d be back in a moment … “I had to freshen up.” I left the table, went past the bathroom and got into my car and drove home.
And when I got home I got the message that he had called. The next day my investigation to his alleged credentials didn’t stand up, he wasn’t licensed or anything. So I called him the next day and said I’d become sick in the bathroom and felt so awful about messing up my shirt … I just had to leave — and he sympathized and asked when he might see me again. I let him know I still felt quite ill and that, hopefully I’d be better by the next session.
And so it came to be that I showed up at the next session and shared everything I knew about Mr. Hartrader with the group. I had a whale of a good time — I’ll never forget the look on his face. Still brings a smile to my lips today.




January 11, 2009 at 2:06 pm
What a GREAT story. I can not believe you did that! Lol, that is like something from a movie. I imagine the look on his face was priceless. What a sleazeball.
January 11, 2009 at 2:36 pm
My contribution to this life includes stories of bizarre moments I’ve witnessed and people I have known. May be my calling. Adds to the challenge of navigating this life FOR SURE. Sharing moments as a girl and a woman would make a good movie. GOOD God, let the ending have humor!
January 11, 2009 at 10:04 pm
WOW! That is so crazy! I wish I could have been a fly on the wall when you unveiled the wolf of his sheep’s clothing! Priceless! :O)
January 11, 2009 at 11:36 pm
I love the quotes on your page. I have an itching desire to steal them always. I am something of a quote hound, but don’t have the ability to retain them! So, to sum it up, good quotes!
January 12, 2009 at 6:30 am
Yes, a wolf in sheeps clothing … another case for tatooing peoples foreheads.
January 16, 2009 at 2:30 pm
I read the book and got a lot out of it. I cannot believe this story! I’m VERY happy about the way you handled it. As I was reading, I was thinking…..why is she being so nice to him??!!
January 16, 2009 at 7:17 pm
Why was I being so nice to him? I didn’t know I was being too nice. Hanging around all these ladies with ‘to puke for stories’ and me with mine. Is THIS what turned him on? His indirect way of communicating he wanted to “see me for dinner” was entirely elusive don’t you think?
January 16, 2009 at 9:00 pm
Oh yes, I totally agree he was an absolute scumbag. I was talking about when you called and made an excuse for leaving the restaurant and that you would still be at the next meeting. I was thinking….WHAT??!! But you had a master plan, to call him out on his BS publicly. It was brilliant!
January 17, 2009 at 11:39 am
Thanks. It helped that I had read the book. I figured he was going to pull the same crap on one of the other ladies. You’d have done the same thing.
I feel like a hug. I confess.